Short answer. A company is profitable when what it keeps from its sales stays positive once you take away the cost of what it sold, the direct costs of each sale (discounts, delivery, returns) and the month's fixed costs. Gross margin alone does not say it. Three readings are enough: the month's cascade, from revenue to result; margin per customer and per product, after direct costs; the break-even point, that is, the revenue to reach in order to cover fixed costs. Almost always, the data already exists in the company, but it is attached to nothing: that attachment is what software builds.
This page is for the manager of a trading, distribution, manufacturing or service company whose revenue rises without the result following, and for the founder based in France who wants to know, from afar, whether their company in Algeria is making money. The definitions come from public sources: gross margin, variable and fixed cost, contribution margin, break-even point, overhead, customer profitability, management accounting. The amounts are those of a constructed example, in thousands of dinars. This is a management result, read by the manager in order to decide: the page covers neither statutory accounting, nor taxation, nor payroll.
From revenue to result: one month's cascade
The figure goes down from a month of sales to what remains.
What gross margin says, and does not say. Gross margin is the difference between revenue and cost of goods sold, divided by revenue. It is not necessarily profit: other expenses, such as sales, administrative and financial costs, must still be deducted. In the example, it is 30%. The middle steps. Discounts granted, deliveries paid for, returns taken back: 1,200 out of 12,000. None of these sums is large; together, they take a third of the gross margin. 20% remains. The last step. The month's fixed costs, 2,150, do not depend on sales. Result: 250, that is 2%.
Why nobody sees it. Each step lives in a different place: the discount on the invoice, delivery with the carrier or in the fuel, the return on a credit note, the rent in a binder. Sales software only adds up what it knows. Management, not accounting. Management accounting serves managers in decision-making; it is primarily forward-looking, where financial accounting is historical. That is what we are talking about here. What this page does not cover. Ranking products and comparing months is the subject of analysing your sales; the cost of a product you manufacture, that of what a finished product costs.
«Thirty percent gross margin at the top, two percent result at the bottom.»
What must be recorded to know it
The figure stacks five layers; the second is the one that is almost always missing.
The cost on the line. Everything starts there: the purchase cost, carried on every sales line at the moment it is made. Without it, there is not even a reliable gross margin. The cost price. It is what the item cost you once on your premises: the purchase, plus what it took to bring it in and make it saleable, inbound transport, packaging, breakage. Variable costs change with quantities; fixed costs do not depend on them. An honest cost price contains only costs that follow the item. The direct costs of a sale. The discount, the delivery, the return: each attaches to a line, an order or a customer.
Fixed costs. A retailer must pay rent and utility bills irrespective of sales. The month's list is short: rents, team, vehicles, subscriptions. It is entered once, dated, and allocated per activity when there are several, as in a group of several companies. The allocation rules. Overheads cannot be immediately associated with a product. Allocating them takes a rule: by revenue, by number of orders, by kilometres. Activity-based costing assigns the cost of each activity to products according to what they actually consume of it. The rule matters little, provided it is written, visible, and the same every month.
Knowing whether you are profitable, in six steps
The figure gives the order of the work; the second step is the longest.
Attach, rather than enter. Almost nothing more needs entering: discounts are on invoices, deliveries in the rounds, returns on credit notes. What is missing is the link. A delivery attached to its order gives a delivery cost per order, as in delivery rounds; a discount attached to its seller gives an average discount per seller, the substance of a margin guard. Margin per axis. Once the links are made, the same cascade is read per customer, per product, per activity, per seller.
Customer profitability. It is the profit the firm makes from serving a customer over a period. Often, the firm finds that some customer relationships are unprofitable, and that a very small percentage of its customers accounts for a large portion of profit. In the example, two customers have the same 30% gross margin. One orders by the pallet and pays cash; the other orders by the carton, is delivered three times a week and returns a tenth of what they take. After direct costs, the first leaves 26%, the second 9%. Reading on a fixed date. The same day every month, the same three screens: an irregular reading changes no decision.
Six reasons why revenue rises and the result does not
The figure gives, for each reason, what is happening and what to measure.
The sales mix. Selling more of the product that earns least raises revenue and lowers the rate: it is the first reason to look at, and the simplest. Discounts. Granted one by one, they are never totalled. Added up per seller and per customer, they become a line of the cascade, and often the easiest to correct. Delivery. Ten small orders cost more to deliver than one large one. A minimum order, or one delivery day per zone, changes the step without touching the price.
The customer who costs. A big customer reassures by their revenue. Margin after direct costs says whether they earn; their payment terms say what they tie up, the subject of customer credit. Result is not cash. Being profitable does not necessarily mean being liquid: a company can fail because of a shortage of cash even while profitable. The month's result can sleep in the stock, as in replenishment, or in invoices not yet collected. The cascade says whether you earn; another reading is needed to say when the money arrives.
The break-even point: how much must be sold
The figure sets six months of sales against the break-even line.
The calculation. The break-even point is the point at which total cost and total revenue are equal: profit there is zero. It can be computed as the point where the contribution from sales equals fixed costs. In the example: 2,150 of fixed costs, a 20% margin after direct costs, hence 10,750 of revenue. What the figure shows. Three months out of six are under the line. Over six months, 65,100 of sales leave 120. The best month, at 12,000, is only 1,250 above the line: that is the margin of safety, how much sales can fall before reaching the break-even point.
Two levers. Lower the line: one fixed cost less, or shared. Raise the rate: fewer discounts, grouped deliveries, a sales mix shifted towards what earns. Two points of rate are worth more than they look: at 22% instead of 20%, the line drops to about 9,770, and all six months move above it. Following it during the month. The break-even point is known on the first day. Each week, the dashboard says where sales stand against it: ahead, on time, behind. It is the only figure of the month that says whether to act before the end.
«The break-even point is known on the first day of the month, not the last.»
Six weeks, in the example
Six weeks for a first cascade read with the manager, one of them a survey.
- What the manager receives: the month's cascade, from revenue to result; margin per customer and per product after direct costs; the break-even point and the lead over it; the allocation rules written down; a monthly reading on a fixed date.
- What the company no longer does: celebrate revenue without knowing what it leaves, grant discounts nobody adds up, keep a customer because they are big, find out at year end that three months out of six were at a loss.
- What is measured: gross margin rate and rate after direct costs; average discount per seller; delivery cost per order; return rate per customer; the month's fixed costs; break-even point and margin of safety.
- What Symloop does: the survey of the data, the cost carried on the lines, attaching discounts, deliveries and returns, entering fixed costs and the allocation rules, the three readings, the connection to your management software or its complement, then the first reading with you.
The survey. One week looking at what sales already record: is there a cost on the lines? Are discounts lines, or prices changed by hand? Do credit notes point back to an invoice? The longest part. Carrying the cost on the lines, then attaching deliveries and returns: three overlapping weeks. Costs and rules. The list of fixed costs and two or three allocation rules, written on one page. The first reading. Done with the manager, figures in hand: whatever surprises is checked line by line before being believed.
What remains afterwards. Three screens: the month's cascade, margin per customer and per product after direct costs, the break-even point and the lead over it. A monthly meeting on a fixed date. What it is not. Neither a balance sheet nor a return: a management result, available a few days after month end, to decide while there is still time. The durations are those of a constructed example: they depend above all on what the sales software already records, and on whether it can be connected to or completed, as for sales management.
- How do I know whether my company is profitable?
- By going down from revenue to result, month by month: cost of goods, then discounts, delivery and returns, then fixed costs. If what remains is positive, the month is profitable. Gross margin alone does not say it.
- How do you calculate the cost price?
- Purchase cost, plus what it took to bring the item to you and make it saleable: transport, packaging, losses. Put in only costs that follow the item; fixed costs are handled separately, in the break-even point.
- How do you calculate gross margin?
- Revenue minus cost of goods sold, all divided by revenue. 12,000 of sales for 8,400 of cost give 3,600, that is 30%. It is not yet a profit.
- What is the difference between gross margin and result?
- Gross margin only takes away the cost of what is sold. The result also takes away discounts, delivery, returns and fixed costs. In this page's example: 30% gross margin, 2% result.
- How do you calculate the break-even point?
- Divide the month's fixed costs by the rate of margin after direct costs. With 2,150 of fixed costs and 20%, 10,750 of revenue is needed to lose nothing. Below that, the month costs money.
- How do I know which customers are profitable?
- By calculating, per customer, the margin after discounts, deliveries and returns, not the gross margin. Two customers at the same gross margin rate can leave 26% and 9% once those costs are counted, as in this page's example.
- Why does revenue rise without the result following?
- Six common reasons: you sell more of what earns least, discounts are growing, delivery costs more, a big customer is costly to serve, fixed costs have gone up, or the result is sleeping in stock and uncollected invoices.
- My company is profitable but I have no cash: why?
- Because result and cash are two things. The month's profit can sit in stock or in invoices not yet collected. A company can run short of money even while profitable.
- Can profitability be followed with Excel?
- For a first calculation, yes: an export of sales and the list of costs are enough. Every month is another matter: attaching discounts, deliveries and returns by hand takes days. That attachment is what a tool automates.
- Is it the same thing as accounting?
- No. It is a management result, made to decide every month, with your own allocation rules. Statutory accounting answers other obligations and another calendar; the two complement each other.